The Linotype Comes West

Printers moved around a good deal in the latter years of the 19th century. They may simply have been looking for better pay, a friendlier boss, or a more comfortable climate. They may have moved on because work was scarce where they were and jobs were available -- or thought to be -- farther down the road. Or they may have traveled on just for the delight of finding out what was around the next corner. They took out a traveling card, depositing it with the local union in the next town when they started to look for work.

Mark Twain had been a printer before his writing won him fame and several fortunes. Henry George--the "single-taxer" candidate who garnered more votes than a young Theodore Roosevelt in the race for New York's mayoralty, though not enough to win--had been a printer and an editor, too, in San Francisco. Horace Greeley, renowned editor of the New York Tribune, had worked at the type case before he took to writing editorials. Bret Harte was another. Many more type-stickers wandered from one office to another. They picked up a few days' work, then moved on or settled down for a longer stay. The very nature of their trade required literacy far beyond that of their fellow unionists. They were often bookish men, fond of ideas and philosophy. For many years, they were almost always first choice to edit the local union paper. They were invariably among the spokesmen and leaders of the union movement.    l

The tramp printer was often an effective channel of communication in a day when other channels were slow, indifferent, and less than complete. He carried word of developments and ideas, useful and otherwise, that had not yet been elevated to the news columns. Blacklisted workers, forced to move on after a strike was lost, became "Johnny Appleseeds" of unionism, spreading its seed as they moved on. So, too, the traveling printer.

As the frontier closed in and cities built up, that kind of mobility lessened. Not the least of the forces that slowed traveling was the development of a typesetting machine. It hit the traveler where be worked--in the skill of his hands in sticking type. A good man at the case could stick up about 1,000 ems, perhaps a little more, in an hour. The reports of the new typesetting machine multiplied that figure many times.

In 1889, a rumor circulated around San Francisco that the Chronicle would soon bring one of these machines to its new office. The machine was said to have been used by the New York Tribune and cost $250,000 to have brought it to its "present condition of perfection." A test in May, 1889, said the Pacific Union Printer, measured the output of thirty-three men working 48 hours. Their average output nearly quadrupled that of a hand compositor. The average cost proved to be 12 cents per 1000 ems--at a time when a hand compositor earned about 50 cents per 1000 ems.

The International Typographical Union, at its 1888 convention, urged local unions to "take speedy action looking to their [the machines'] recognition, endeavoring every where to secure their operation by union men upon a scale of wages that shall secure compensation equal to that paid hand compositors." The convention of the following year enacted the union's basic law:

"The International Typographical Union directs that in all offices within its jurisdiction where typesetting machines are used, practical printers shall be employed to run them and also that subordinate unions shall regulate the scale on such machines."

At the outset, apprentices were prohibited from operating the machine, but in time that work was slowly added to their training. To avoid displacement of union members special rates of pay were often set for learners--that is, journeymen who wished to learn to operate them. The ITU strongly discouraged any attempt, if any printer was inclined to try, to compete with the machine's increased productivity by reducing hand rates or working longer hours.

The machine came west under less than auspicious economic conditions. The early 1890s witnessed another severe, prolonged depression. Unemployment soared and Local 21 closed the city to traveling cards. Commented the Union Printer, "The job offices are complaining of dullness and some of the newspapers are not employing as many men as they did a few months ago." Prosperity returned by the middle of the decade and the city faced the new century under a brighter economic sky.

In 1894, a machine scale committee of Local 21 laid down the principles by which the introduction of the typesetting machine would be managed: piece work on the machines was prohibited; the eight-hour day was to be established; members of the union "who will be most affected by the introduction of the machines" were to be given the opportunity of learning to operate them. The Pacific Union Printer warned members that "to vote against the scale with the idea that a failure to adopt a machine scale will in the slightest degree  retard the introduction of machines is an absurdity patent to the most unreasonable."

The committee set a scale of $27 a week on morning newspapers, $24 on all other classes of work. The hours of labor were set at 48 per week and were to be reduced to seven-and-a-half per day or 45 per week within the next two years. The scale remained in effect until April, 1903. At that time the machine scale was raised $3 a week. Introduction of the machine was more rapid in newspaper offices than in commercial shops. Large quantities of composition in relatively short bursts could be coupled more easily to reductions in hours of work. In book and job offices, the machine was slower in catching on and employers raised strong objections to a shorter work day. When Local 21 turned its attention to that problem, it ran into deep trouble.

  

Once the Linotype was introduced, automated typesetting replaced hand compositors,
but increased the overall number of printers needed to produce larger newspapers.